26

Does this video authentically depict a hurricane, as seen from the sky?

Image of cloud taken from plane window

I wonder if perhaps this is an AI-generated video . Wouldn’t it be risky to fly close to a hurricane? Why would it form a circle perpendicular to the Earth rather than parallel to it?

2
  • 3
    The caption given in the link is "Passenger Captures Hurricane Melissa From the Sky: Caribbean Devasted". While the plane flies serenely by. There is another more credible video here on which this one may have been based. Commented Nov 1 at 11:22
  • 17
    +1 for an AI skeptic post Commented Nov 1 at 17:04

1 Answer 1

53

No, On the 29th of October 2025 this video was uploaded by @earthimpacts to TikTok who labelled the video as AI generated:

From high above, clouds curve perfectly into a giant circular formation, creating a hollow ring you can see straight through. The surreal, gravity-defying shape floats in the sky, glowing softly in the sunlight, giving an unreal, mesmerizing aerial view.

#earthimpacts #fblifestyle #cloudcircle #aerialview #ai

This content isn’t real — it’s a simulated ‘what if’ scenario created by AI for visual exploration.

The Instagram video you linked to was uploaded a day later, on the 30th, featuring the same 8-second clip but described as footage of Hurricane Melissa:

One of the strongest storms ever recorded in the Caribbean — Hurricane Melissa — has struck Jamaica and Cuba, leaving widespread destruction in its path.

A passenger captured this dramatic footage from an airplane window as the storm unleashed its full force over the region.

Data from FlightRadar, a real-time flight tracker map, shows that commercial flights have been rerouting to avoid the hurricane (Business Insider, 29 Oct 2025):

A map published by FlightRadar at around 8 a.m. ET on Wednesday shows how flights to and from the US are avoiding the hurricane, which is the most powerful ever to hit Jamaica.

A video purportedly showing Hurricane Melissa from an aircraft would likely include visible signs of heavy turbulence.

According to the Hurricane Hunters, a team within the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), their aircraft encountered “heavy turbulence” while flying through Melissa, prompting an “inspection before returning to operations” (Hurricane Hunters, 28 Oct 2025):

A 53rd Weather Reconnaissance Squadron crew (call sign TEAL 75), known as the Air Force Reserve Hurricane Hunters, is returning to it's forward operating location in Curaçao after encountering heavy turbulence today while entering the eye of Hurricane Melissa, a Category 5 storm.

During the event, the aircraft briefly experienced forces stronger than normal due to turbulence. While this does not automatically indicate damage, standard safety procedures require an inspection before returning to operations.

4
  • 1
    Well, the reconnaissance aircraft flew deliberately into the hurricane while a high-flying aircraft might stay above it. I don't find canonical information right away but some hurricanes may not reach above 30,000 feet. Commented Nov 3 at 2:29
  • 13
    @Peter-ReinstateMonica The AI video was at the cloud level. Some clouds even pass by the aeroplane window. The general action of commercial airliners was to avoid it completely. I too found no information on height, but on the 27th Oct, NOAA reported "cloud tops colder than -80 deg C" which are temperatures found at the tropopause which is 56,000 ft at the equator. Commented Nov 3 at 3:11
  • 4
    Apparently, "simulated" weather now need not involve any actual simulation, and can just be the artistic impression of a video generator. Commented Nov 4 at 3:28
  • 1
    For the aircraft nerds: aircraft flying in bad weather are supposed to stay below their designed 'Rough Air Speed' to limit the structural loads. At that speed the wing should stall before producing enough lift to damage itself. That's how the research aircraft can fly through a hurricane safely. An airliner wouldn't want to slow down, plus it's still extremely uncomfortable. Commented Nov 4 at 16:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.