8

In the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode, "Best of Both Worlds",

Picard is assimilated by the Borg but then rescued and returned to normal by the Enterprise crew.

Seeing as they now knew how to free people from the Borg, why couldn't the same technique be used on anyone who was assimilated after that? The Borg appear plenty more times and assimilate characters, especially in the movie First Contact.

(Picard even advises the crew not to hesitate to kill any assimilated colleagues, even claiming they'll be doing them a favour - good thing that attitude wasn't taken with you, Jean Luc!)

7
  • 1
    Well, according to Memory Beta there were as many as - or perhaps more than - 50 trillion Borg. It would keep the enterprise crew busy for a while (and very bored). Think how long and how much trouble Janeway had with Seven/Anika because she'd been part of the collective for so long. Picard had been a fully formed adult and didn't stay Borg for long. Seems like the young ones can be more easily turned than the long-term ones. Commented yesterday
  • 1
    Soldiers during a battle don't try to negotiate ideology unless they've a deathwish. Survival would top the priority list then. Commented yesterday
  • 3
    Not making this an answer because I cannot verify what I believe to know: A lot of Piccard that is usually erased by assimilation was left intact, because the queen was looking for a sort of emissary. Piccard was not turned into an ordinary drone. IIRC 7 of 9 was also not "just" liberated but did go through a bit of a process before most of her implants could be removed. After that she learns for seasons how to be human. Borg drones cannot simply be restored to human form. Commented yesterday
  • There is this answer scifi.stackexchange.com/a/301118/7616 supporting much of what I think to know. Commented yesterday
  • Shouldn't Hugh also be discussed here? Commented 17 hours ago

1 Answer 1

13

Picard is a special case: He was not turned into a regular drone, but into Locutus of Borg with the specific purpose to use Picard's expertise to lead the Borg's assimilation of the Federation. I don't recall this being explicitly stated on screen, but seems very natural to me that this meant that Picard's transformation into Locutus was less destructive to his personality than a typical Borg assimilation.

We see other cases of Borg drones becoming individuals again (Hugh in TNG, several examples in Voyager, most prominently Seven). However, they didn't return to being the person they were before. Seven is Seven, not Annika. Unimatrix Zero aside, it would seem to me that killing a Borg drone isn't killing a person - the person they were is gone, and the person they might become if liberated doesn't exist yet.

This is perspective is reinforced in the first season of Picard, where we see a derelict Borg cube being reclaimed. The liberated Borg drones are referred to as xBorg, and this seems to be their primary social identity. They don't just get some surgery and then go home to resume their former lives.

From a medical perspective it seems to make a big difference how long someone was a Borg drone. Picard was only Locutus for a short time, and it was possible to just remove the Borg implants and heal his body. Seven's borg implants are so deeply integrated into her body that the Doctor couldn't remove all of them. (Of course this isn't relevant to the recently assimilated crew members in First Contact.)

2
  • Seven eventually goes by Annika and regains her memories of her family. Commented yesterday
  • 7
    Picard also had severe mental and physical pain and problems for months, if not years, after his assimilation. He would know better than most how bad that was for him and that he might "not wish that on my worst enemy" kind of experience. Commented yesterday

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.