Python: 'ValueError: can only convert an array of size 1 to a Python scalar' when looping over rows in pd.DataFrame

I would like to loop over the rows of a DataFrame, in my case to calculate strength ratings for a number of sports teams.

The DataFrame columns 'home_elo' and 'away_elo' contain the pre-match strength rating (ELO score) of the teams involved and are updated in the row of the next home / away match after the match (each team has two strength ratings at any point in time, for home and away games), with what update_elo(a,b,c) returns.

The respective code snippet looks as follows:

for index in df.index:

    counter = counter + 1
    # Calculation of post-match ELO scores for home and away teams
    if df.at[index,'updated'] == 2: # Update next match ELO scores if not yet updated but pre-match ELO scores available

        try:
            all_home_fixtures = df.date_rank[df['localteam_id'] == df.at[index,'localteam_id']]
            next_home_fixture = all_home_fixtures[all_home_fixtures > df.at[index,'date_rank']].min()
            next_home_index = df[(df['date_rank'] == next_home_fixture) & (df['localteam_id'] == df.at[index,'localteam_id'])].index.item()
        except ValueError:
            print('ERROR 1 at' + str(index))
            df.at[index,'updated'] = 4

        try:
            all_away_fixtures = df.date_rank[df['visitorteam_id'] == df.at[index,'visitorteam_id']]
            next_away_fixture = all_away_fixtures[all_away_fixtures > df.at[index,'date_rank']].min()
            next_away_index = df[(df['date_rank'] == next_away_fixture) & (df['visitorteam_id'] == df.at[index,'visitorteam_id'])].index.item()
        except ValueError:
            print('ERROR 2 at' + str(index))
            df.at[index,'updated'] = 4

        # print('Current: ' + str(df.at[index,'fixture_id']) + '; Followed by: ' + str(next_home_fixture))
        # print('Current date rank: ' + str(df.at[index,'date']) + ' ' + str(df.at[index,'date_rank']) + '; Next home date rank: ' + str(df.at[next_home_index,'date_rank']) + '; Next away date rank: ' + str(df.at[next_away_index,'date_rank']))

        df.at[next_home_index, 'home_elo'] = update_elo(df.at[index,'home_elo'],df.at[index,'away_elo'],df.at[index,'actual_score'])
        df.at[next_away_index, 'away_elo'] = update_elo(df.at[index,'away_elo'],df.at[index,'home_elo'],1 - df.at[index,'actual_score']) # Swap function inputs for away team


        df.at[next_home_index, 'updated'] = df.at[next_home_index, 'updated'] + 1
        df.at[next_away_index, 'updated'] = df.at[next_away_index, 'updated'] + 1

        df.at[index,'updated'] = 3

The code works fine for the first couple of rows. I then, however, encounter errors, always for the same rows, even though I cannot see how the rows would differ from others.

1. If I do not handle the ValueError as shown above, I receive the error message ValueError: can only convert an array of size 1 to a Python scalar for the first time after about 250 rows.
2. If I do handle the ValueError as shown above, I capture four such errors, two for each of the error-handling blocks (the code works fine otherwise), but the code stops updating any further strength ratings after about 18% of all rows, without throwing any error message.

I would very much appreciate it if you could help me (a) understand what causes the error and (b) how to handle them.

Since this is my first post on StackOverflow, I am not yet fully aware of the common posting practices of the forum. Please let me know if there is anything I can improve about my post.

Thank you very much!